New Page 1
 
 
Beyond Prison
To film is to rehabilitate in Traverse City, Michigan
Ashley Tisue
2008 | Master of Architecture
A person, a community member who does not abide by the rules of society and is thus punished by not being able to remain in it. He is removed from it and placed in an alternative community…one that differs drastically from the one from which he was removed. It is expected that he will one day return to that former society. But for a predetermined amount of time, he remains in this alternative community that is a world unto itself, harsher, colder, and darker than normal society. Time stands still, and he takes for granted that the outside world will remain as it was at the time of his transition…yet sporadically he catches glimpses – through song lyrics, family visits, or written letters – that time has most certainly moved on in the outside world, even though his environment changes very negligibly. Change in the ‘outside world’ is inevitable. In light of the trepidation of this realization, soon this alternative – though seemingly less desirable – community represents all he knows and is comfortable with, and he no longer feels any connection to society “out there.”

Ultimately though, he will be returning to society outside of the walls of the inner alternative community, unprepared and fearing the hoops and hurdles that he will have to jump through and over to adjust. Instead of free cable and no responsibilities, he will have to demonstrate ability sufficient for finding a job and making a living. Yet little in this alternative community has prepared him for doing this. He doesn’t even remember how to live out there.

In light of this, what was the purpose of the time spent in the alternative society? Was it to inflict punishment? Because if that is the case, it should have ended upon release into greater society…and yet the punishment – now in the form of inability and helplessness - remains. Was it for rehabilitation? Evidently not, as he returns to greater society no more ready to be a contributing member of it than before he was locked away.
 

New Page 1